top of page
Sunlight on young seedling apple trees
Beautiful mature seedling apple tree on Ashdown Forest
Mummified apple on branch silhouetted against winter sky

Research & Trials

 

Fruit for a changing climate
 

Alongside my consultancy I run research on finding, testing and conserving apples for Cornwall's future. That means wild seedling apples, Cornwall's own endemic varieties, and trial orchards to find out what really performs here.
 

Our orchards face a climate that is changing faster than any in living memory. Winters are milder and wetter, springs are less predictable, and summers bring more drought and heat stress. Disease pressure is shifting too. Most of the apple varieties grown in Britain were selected for the conditions of the last two centuries, not the next one. So I am asking a practical question: what will grow well in Cornwall in fifty years' time, and where will we find it?
 

I believe part of the answer is already growing in our hedges.


 

Some Interesting Apples

Some Interesting Apples (SIA) is a project I co-founded in 2019 with the artist William Arnold. Its aim is to record and, where their qualities justify it, preserve wilding apples. These are Malus domestica growing on their own roots in hedges, verges, dunes and waste ground, usually where someone once threw an apple core.
 

The apple does not come true from seed. Every pip is a genetic lottery, so every wilding is a new variety that has never existed before. Most are unremarkable. But each one has germinated, established and fruited without help, under real Cornish conditions. Together they make a vast, unplanned breeding trial, and nobody had been looking at the results.

  • Mapping. Since 2019 we have found and recorded more than 800 wildings across Cornwall. Each tree is logged with a unique what3words location. Some of the richest populations are in the old Camborne and Redruth mining district and on coastal dune systems.

  • Evaluation. Every autumn since 2020 we have held a public pomological exhibition and taste trial at Kestle Barton on the Helford. Fruit gathered from wildings is described, photographed, tasted and scored, by experts and by the public. The trial also welcomes donations of fruit from genuine accidental seedlings.

  • Research partnership. Since 2022 the project has worked with Professor Caitlin DeSilvey of the University of Exeter. The work is extending into genetic fingerprinting of selected wildings to trace their parentage, and into the cultural history of 'wild' apples.

  • Partners and supporters: the National Trust, Forest for Cornwall, Kestle Barton, the University of Exeter, the Norwegian Research Council and Arts & Culture Exeter.


The Wilding Mother Orchard

The best wildings from the trials are being conserved and tested in the Wilding Mother Orchard. It is on National Trust land at Penarvon, near Helford, and is managed jointly by SIA and the National Trust's Lizard and Penrose team, with planting support from Forest for Cornwall. We believe it is the first orchard in the UK devoted solely to wild-grown, chance-seedling apples.
 

In February 2024 we planted 80 rootstocks: MM111, M26 and seedling Malus sylvestris, our native crab apple. Scion wood from selected wildings was grafted onto them in situ after the fact. Using several rootstocks lets us see how each selection behaves at different vigours. As the trees come into bearing, the orchard becomes a living gene bank and a trial ground. We will be recording vigour, disease resistance, flowering time, cropping and fruit quality.


Seedling fruit and climate resilience

SIA rests on a simple principle. Named varieties are clones, each fixed at the moment it was selected. Seedlings are new genetic combinations, and the wildings that thrive have already passed a natural screening for local conditions. Selecting from that diversity is the oldest form of apple breeding. Many of our best-loved varieties began as chance seedlings. It may also be one of the fastest routes to resilient top fruit: varieties suited to warmer, wetter and more erratic seasons, and less reliant on sprays.

The work also connects to wider progeny trials.
 

Trialling Cornwall's endemic varieties

Cornwall's own apples evolved, or were selected, in a mild, damp, salt-wind climate. That may already be closer to the future of much of Britain than the conditions most commercial varieties were bred for. Many of these Cornish varieties survive as a handful of old trees, and few have ever been assessed systematically.
 

I am now establishing experimental orchards to test Cornish endemic varieties side by side under consistent conditions. Each variety will be recorded over successive seasons for:

  • vigour, tree habit and response to pruning

  • resistance to canker, scab and mildew in a wet maritime climate

  • tolerance of exposure, waterlogging and drought

  • flowering period, frost risk and pollination compatibility

  • regularity of cropping, yield and keeping quality

  • fruit quality for dessert, culinary, juice and cider use


The goal is evidence, not nostalgia. I want to establish which heritage varieties deserve wider planting in Cornwall's new orchards, and which are best kept as conserved genetic resources.
 

How the research shapes my consultancy

This work feeds directly into the advice I give clients. When I recommend varieties for a new orchard or fruit hedge, I draw on direct observation of how trees actually perform in Cornish conditions. Where it suits the brief, I can include tested Cornish varieties and promising seedling selections. That gives a planting genetic breadth as well as a proven core.
 

Get involved

  • Taste trials: join the annual Some Interesting Apples exhibition and taste trial at Kestle Barton each October.

  • Donate fruit: if you know of an apple tree that has grown by chance from a discarded core or a bird-sown pip, we would like to hear about it. Genuine wildings only, please, not garden or orchard trees.

  • Collaborate: I welcome contact from landowners, researchers, nurseries and orchard groups interested in trialling material or hosting a trial planting.

​

Contact me →

​

​

vagrant cider logo
Vagrant's Pomona artwork
  • Black Instagram Icon
bottom of page